EPSOM SCHOOL BOARD
EPSOM CENTRAL SCHOOL
EPSOM, NEW HAMPSHIRE

WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 7, 2005 6:00 P.M.

MINUTES OF MEETING

 

Present:               

Board Members:     Andrew Turnbull (chair), Gordon Ellis, Barbara Doughty

David Dziura -           Assistant Superintendent of SAU 53 Schools

Patrick Connors –      ECS Principal

Richard Dougherty –  ECS Vice Principal

Tracey Miner -           secretary

 

Excused –                  Bill Yeaton

 

Citizen/Staff:  Tony Cacciola, Lisa Strano, Janet Allen, Carol Verity, Darlene Roy, Diane Lewis, Jon Harwood, Jr., Lee L. Bird, Bianca Bird, Lauren Naugle, Vicki Naugle, Shannon Bentzler, Lynne Lesieur, Jan Santosuosso, Chelsea Jarest, Amanda Taillon, Colleen Steinbeiser, Carolyn Steinbeiser, Molly Todd, Mary Beth Magan, David Goulet, Don Harty, Tamy Anderson

 

Agenda Item 1.     Call to Order – by Andrew Turnbull at 6:03 PM

 

Agenda Item 2.     Pledge of Allegiance – lead by Gordon Ellis

 

Agenda Item 3.     Minutes of Previous Meeting – November 21, 2005.  5B - put Richard Dougherty’s name where Patrick’s is.  Add Barbara’s name as in attendance.

 

Gordon Ellis made a motion to accept the minutes as revised.

Barbara 2nd.

 

                        THE MOTION CARRIED ON A VOTE OF 3 - 0

                        Gordon Ellis -             aye

                        Barbara Doughty –     aye

                        Andrew Turnbull –     aye

 

 

Immediate Business

 

Agenda Item 4A.  Agenda Review

Agenda will be followed as written.

 

Agenda Item 4B.  Citizens’/Staff Comments

Janet Allen relayed a message from Lisa Bauer to thank the board and the administration for their hard work with the new HQT requirements for the teachers..

 

Agenda Item 4C.  Administrators’ Report

 

Patrick Connors handed out an Administrator’s Report, which he discussed.  Wreath sales helped defrayed a large portion of the Mi_Te_Na costs.  The PTO held a successful Santa’s Workshop and a week-long Book Fair.  Drama Club has started signups for auditions for Aladdin and His Wonderful, Magical Lamp.  Patrick discussed the Math-a-thon, organized by Ms. Strano.  The school has started a Respect and Behavior Recognition Program with eagles to be placed in the hallway.  Patrick discussed the uniforms for cheerleading, which will cost about $460, which includes lettering.  Patrick spoke with Michelle Ricco from the drug alcohol and tobacco program.  They are ready to present to the school and parents in January.  Two donations were made to the school.  (Discussion about these is later in the minutes.)  The Geography Bee will be open to the public.  Gordon Ellis asked if new wax needs to be purchased for the new machines.

 

Agenda Item 4D. Advisory Building Committee Report

No one was yet in attendance for this.  This agenda item will be moved to later in the meeting, as it is known that Mr. Harty will be attending the meeting tonight.

 

Agenda Item 4E. Mini-courses and Science Fair

 

Lynne Lesieur handed out the Mini-courses signup forms.  “You’re Fired” and Archery are new this year.  Gordon Ellis asked how many children signed up for each course, and Lynne read off the numbers for the board.  Lynne said that the way that the signups were done this year was much more efficient, as more courses were available in both the AM and the PM sessions.  Everyone student got something from their first through third choices.  Lynne wanted to also thank her volunteers who worked so hard getting the names assigned:  Michelle Pinsonneault, Sharon Gelinas and Sharon Streeter.  Andrew Turnbull asked how children were being transported to the courses that were not held at the school.  Lynne said that the busses are being paid for through the BOXTOPS program.  $1300 was turned in from spring and fall.

 

Carol Verity discussed the 6th grade science fair, which will be separate from the 7th and 8th grade fairs, as they would spend more time working on the process.  Students were given a list of twelve topics to choose from, with a maximum of three students choosing each topic.  She is going to coordinate with the English teachers for the public speaking part of reports.  Children are expected to do this as an individual effort, no teams.  Parents can help, but the end result has to be the child’s effort.

 

Darlene Roy discussed the 7th and 8th grade science fair.  They present their projects in the classroom.  They also set up in the gym, and present to the whole school, and in the evening, they present to the public.  The students have been asked to choose a topic that has an experimental component to it, as that is part of the overall SAU 53 rubric that was developed as a guidance for science fairs.  Fifteen of the strongest presenters will go to PA.  Barbara Doughty asked what prevents kids from reusing last year’s project.  Darlene explained that the teachers do track that.  However, a student can do a variation or a continuance of what they did previously.  The English department will help with the presentation aspect of the project. 

 

Darlene Roy has been involved with a group of teachers to revise the science curriculum to align it with the upcoming state science standards.  This has been a three-year process.  The group wants to share this with the school board.  Barbara Doughty asked that this be placed on the agenda for January.

 

Gordon Ellis asked if there was any thought about having the whole school do the science fair.  Darlene Roy said that the level of effort to produce the type of work that is required by the science fair was geared to the upper grade levels, but she certainly didn’t see why the lower grade levels could not have something along the lines of a “Science Share” where they could work on areas that younger children could be excited about.

 

Agenda Item 4F.   Donation to School

 

Patrick Connors read a letter, making a donation of $50 for purchasing children’s books in the name of Robert Mantone, whose grandchildren, Ryan and Jacob McDonald attend the school.  Patrick also presented a donation from the Martial Arts School of Tae Kwan Do of two gift certificates for $149.

 

Barbara Doughty made a motion to accept the Robert Mantone donation on behalf of the McDonald children.

Gordon 2nd.

                               

                        THE MOTION CARRIED ON A VOTE OF 3 - 0

                        Gordon Ellis -             aye

                        Barbara Doughty –     aye

                        Andrew Turnbull –     aye

 

Gordon Ellis made a motion to accept the gift certificates from the martial arts school to be managed by the administration.

Barbara 2nd.

                               

                        THE MOTION CARRIED ON A VOTE OF 3 - 0

                        Gordon Ellis -             aye

                        Barbara Doughty –     aye

                        Andrew Turnbull –     aye

 

Agenda Item 4D. Advisory Building Committee Report

 

Dan Harty spoke for the Building Advisory Committee which met last week.  In May/June the committee wanted to go forward with the 8-room addition and renovations.  Enrollment expectations were supposed to be the same, or go up.  The committee asked the school board for updated enrollment projections.  Projections from last year showed that over the next 10 years, enrollment would go up to the 620 – 630 range.  Enrollment at the beginning of the school year this year was about 469.  The School Board Association put a projection together that shows that future enrollment is actually going to start dropping.

Depending on which study you look at, enrollment ten years from now will be in the 460 – 470 range, or as low as 400.  Therefore, the Building Advisory Committee voted to recommend to the school board that they not go forward with the proposal we had last year for an 8-room expansion and renovations.

 

Much discussion was held about the existing building problems and how to resolved them.  It was noted that, since the proposal was an addition, the state supplemented us, including the renovations.  Now, since there is no addition, the town would have to foot the whole bill.  David Goulet spoke to the advantages and/or disadvantages of having the needed repairs and renovations placed in the budget or in a warrant article.  Gordon Ellis suggested that the school board charge the committee again next spring.  Andrew Turnbull thanked the Building Committee for their help.

 

 

Old/Unfinished Business

 

Agenda Item 5A.  School District Treasurer

 

Patrick Connors said that Mary Wagner expressed interest in the position.  Gordon Ellis spoke to Linda Martel, who felt that she could jump in and take it over, but she did not want to run for the position in March.  Dave Dzirua said that the position needs to be filled by January 1st.  The school board felt that they would be able to have the position filled within a few weeks.

 

Agenda Item 5B. School Board Stipends

 

Dave Dziura explained that school board stipends are paid semi-annually.  All other districts’ stipends have already been paid.  Some Epsom school board members had expressed that they wanted their stipend returned to the school budget.  Partial school board terms, relative to stipends, were discussed.  Dave said that the SAU had no precedence from Epsom for handling partial stipends, or stipends that are returned to the school budget.  The board decided that this would be discussed at the next meeting, when all members would be in attendance.

 

Agenda Item 5C. 2006/07 Budget Development

 

Dave Dziura talked about a new health insurance proposal for 06/07 school year from HealthTrust, a service of the New Hampshire Local Government Center.  In the spring, the SAU was directed to seek alternatives for employee health insurance, as there have been double-digit cost increases for several years in succession.  Several years ago, HealthTrust was the district’s insurance provider.  The district is currently under the School Care consortium, which is subcontracted by CIGNA.  The board then had a lengthy discussion about the pros and cons of staying with the current insurer, or switching to HealthTrust.  The HealthTrust plan showed that the employees would pay less, and have more benefits.  The board asked Patrick Connors to have a get together with the staff to present this information, and see if they want to make the change to HealthTrust.

 

The board discussed the difficulties of filling substitute teaching positions, and the impact to the budget and the school, especially when this results in pulling a paraprofessional or an aid from another room.  Dave Dziura mentioned that if this were a problem, it would have come up, because it would have shown up in a state audit.  Rich Dougherty indicated that approximately 10 – 15% of the time we’re pulling someone from another area to cover, rather than getting a sub, as a sub is not available.

 

Barbara Doughty asked if there was money in the budget for assisting the teachers with the Praxis II for those that want to take it?  Patrick Connors said that based on recent news as to HQT status for Epsom teachers, there was only a handful of people left that need to be funded, and that an additional $1500 would cover the cost.  This should be added to the inservice training line item.  A lot of money has already been spent out of Title II funds for this.  Anyone that will be newly hired must already be HQT, so this won’t come up for any new hires.

 

The board decided to raise the treasurer’s salary line item from $1000 to $1500.

 

Dave Dziura presented a quote from Dail for one bus at $32,535, but if we have more students than one bus holds, then you have to put on another bus.  The board discussed the issue, as it related to the budget, safety, parking and crowding.  It was the consensus to put this in a warrant article at $65,070 for two busses.

 

Dave Dziura distributed a hand-out showing the new Epsom tax rates.  There was a lengthy discussion as to the impact from the new property assessment and the tax rates.  Because of the great percentage increase in property evaluations, there was a significant decrease in the tax rate.

 

The board then discussed the need to fix the boiler.  It was requested that Patrick Connors get a revised quote to fix the boiler.  Last year’s quote was between $50,000 – 55,000.  The SAU will add the new quoted amount to the proper line item when the quote comes in.

 

The board discussed the new phone system, and if that was going to come out of this year’s budget or next year’s budget.  The board decided to go ahead with the update to the phone system from this year’s budget.  This would put a phone in each classroom.  The phones would also be part of the intercom system.  This was especially important for the modular classrooms that don’t have any phone lines in them.  Quotes would be obtained, and the work scheduled for the spring time, when the budget surplus would be more certain.  It was believed that the cost would be approximately $40,000.

 

Budget initiatives were discussed.  There were seven initiatives that were brought forward.  The results of discussion of these initiatives are as follows:

 

1 - Additional Special Education case manager – $51,782.

Added into budget.

 

2 – Kindergarten teacher from Grant to Fund 1 – $56,668

Added into the budget.

 

3 – Stipend for School Chorus – $756

Added into the budget.

 

4 – Cross Country Team – $1,700

Added into the budget.

 

5 – Sub custodial service – $2,880

Added into the budget.

 

6 – Tractor/Lawnmower - $7,000

Added into the budget.

 

7 – Asbestos Abatement - $81,327

Not added to the budget.  Dave Dziura explained that a few years ago, an environmental firm came into the school to find out what parts of the school had asbestos.  This was the amount of the quote for a complete replacement of everything that was asbestos.  However, there is currently nothing that is exposed, so there is no current need for this work.

 

Dave Dziura brought up the issue of expendable trust warrant articles.  The two most common things that they are used for are building repairs and special education, because this impact could easily put a budget into deficit.  For an expendable trust, the school board can be named as the agent to expend, but this requires a majority vote of the board, and a public hearing.

 

Dick Fowler shared some views and concerns about the board’s use of surplus money during a default budget year, and how the voters view that.  Dave Dziura added that the thing that is helpful with the expendable trust is that a warrant article could fund an expendable trust out of a budget surplus, so that when a future deficit budget situation happens, there is a means for offsetting that deficit.  However, the purpose of the money must be stated.

 

 

New Business

 

Dave Dziura distributed the Epsom Capital Improvements Program 2005 – 2010 that was done last year for the town.  A request was received to update this by December 14th.  The following edits were made to the list:

 

 

  • “Epsom Central School Building Expansion” was removed from the list.
  • “Network Server Purchase and Setup” was removed from the list.
  • “Heating/Ventilation Update” – strike the “(if renovation/expansion not approved)” part, and strike this part of the last sentence:  “upgrade at the time of building expansion or”
  • “Boiler Replacement – ECS” - dates were changed to the 2006 – 2007 school year.  The following line was stricken:  “Boiler replacement in the event proposed building expansion project is not approved/completed.”
  • “Reface Old Fiberglass Exterior Wall System” - strike the “(if renovation/expansion not approved)” part.
  • “New Lawn /Snow Tractor” was removed from the list (is in the budget).

 

Agenda Item 6A. Assistant Superintendent Search

Dave Dziura distributed a timeline for carrying out the search.  Fifteen applications have been received so far.  By March 2006, the Screening Committee will have selected 3 – 4 finalists.  The Screening Committee needs to be kept to seven members:  one representative from each of the five districts, and two from the SAU office.  Then, school board members will meet with the finalists.  The school boards are the ones that will decide who will fill the position.  Because the Assistant Superintendent  will be working most closely with Chichester and Epsom, it was decided that these two towns need to assign a board member and an administrator, one each.  At Chichester’s meeting on Monday, they chose to have a board member, which means that Epsom needs to chose an administrator.  Dave Dziura requested that the board confirm Patrick Connors as the representative to the committee.  The board did confirm Patrick’s nomination to the committee.

 

Agenda Item 6B. Progress Report: School Year Committee - Ms. Doughty

This will be placed on January’s agenda.

 

 

Other Business

 

Agenda Item 7A. Citizens’/Staff Comments

 

Tracey Miner asked why the board would decide to spend money on revising the phone system, when the boiler is in such desperate need of repair?  Barbara Doughty (and several of the teachers in attendance) commented that the phones are a serious safety issue.  Gordon Ellis said that the boiler is something that can only be done in the summer time.

 

Shannon Bentzler, whose kindergarten teaching position was discussed during the meeting, wanted to be sure that the board understood her educational background.  She stated that it has been two years since she received her master’s degree.

 

John Harwood said that the board needed to consider what people are spending out of their own budgets at home.  John mentioned his $1,000 tax increase with the new town property assessment, doubling the cost of oil and doubling the cost of gasoline.  He suggested that a school budget increase of 9-10% is going to scare the voters, as they have already had too many increases this year.  Andrew Turnbull commented that, even though he could sympathize with what John was saying, when looking at the budget, there really is no “extra” or anything extravagant in it.  John said that he didn’t see the school board looking for ways to cut expenses.  Andrew said that that is because they don’t come to the meetings, and they don’t see the process of how much work has been put into getting the numbers down to a bare bones budget.  Barbara Doughty iterated that very little of the budget is discretionary spending.  John said that the board put hiring someone to vacuum a room on the budget, but if a teacher has a little spare time during the day, they could run a vacuum.  Barbara said that, contractually, the board can not have teachers vacuuming.

 

John Harwood mentioned that we need more volunteerism in this town.  John mentioned the library that is going up, and considered it to be extravagant, for the size of the town.  His understanding was that no money was donated for it, but that misconception was corrected.  John talked about a tax break for volunteerism.  Quit spending when we don’t have to spend.

 

Shannon Bentzler defended the kindergarten teachers’ efforts, in that they are cleaning their classrooms all day long, in a typical day, out of necessity, and because they care so much about the children’s health.  They already spend their spare time cleaning the rooms, just to keep it at a usable state.

 

At 11:08P.M., Gordon Ellis made a motion to enter non-public session under RSA 91-A:3II(a) in order to discuss employee compensation.

Barbara 2nd.

                                                                                                 

                        THE MOTION CARRIED ON A VOTE OF 3 - 0

                        Gordon Ellis -             aye

                        Barbara Doughty –     aye

                        Andrew Turnbull –     aye

 

Present in non-public session were:  Andrew Turnbull, Barbara Doughty, Gordon Ellis, Dave Dziura, Patrick Connors, and Richard Dougherty.

 

At 11:35 P.M. Gordon Ellis made a motion to end the non-public session.  Barbara Doughty seconded the motion.

 

                        Barbara Doughty -      aye

                        Gordon Ellis -             aye

                        Andrew Turnbull -      aye

 

School Board chairman, Andrew Turnbull, announced that the Board had taken no action while in non-public session.

 

Gordon Ellis made a motion that the Board include in its budget proposal for 2006/07, sufficient funds to cover 4.5% wage rate increases for the school’s two hourly custodial positions, for the two non-union secretarial positions, and for the lunch program personnel; a 4.5% salary increase for the school’s technology coordinator; and 5.0% increases for the assistant principal, special education coordinator and head custodial position.  Barbara Doughty seconded the motion.

 

THE MOTION CARRIED ON A VOTE OF 3 AYES AND 0 NAYES

 

                        Barbara Doughty -      aye

                        Gordon Ellis -             aye

                        Andrew Turnbull -      aye

 

Agenda Item 8.           Adjournment

 

At 11:38 P.M., hearing no call for further business to be conducted by the Board, Andrew Turnbull adjourned the meeting.

 

Next Scheduled Meeting will be Wednesday, January 4, 2006, at 6:00PM.

 

Agenda Item 9. Informational Items