Deerfield School Board

Deerfield Community School

Deerfield, New Hampshire

Thursday, November 16, 2006 

 

MINUTES OF MEETING 

PRESENT: John Harrington, Bonnie Beaubien, Kevin Barry, Kevin Webber, Paul Yergeau, Tom Haley, Don Gorman, Kandy Davitt

1.  Call To Order-Mr. Harrington 

 

The November 11, 2006 DCS Board meeting was called to order at 6:30 PM by Chair John Harrington. 

 

2. Pledge of Allegiance 

    Mr. Harrington led those present in the Pledge of Allegiance.  

3.  Minutes of Previous Meetings  

 

 

 

Pg. 1   

At 6:48 P.M., a motion to enter non-public session under RSA 91-A:3II(c) to discuss a personnel matter was made by Kevin Barry, seconded by Kevin Webber.  On a roll call, the board voted:

 

John Harrington            YES

                                                        Kevin Barry                 YES

Bonnie Beaubien           YES

Donald Gorman            YES

       Kevin Webber               YES

 

THE MOTION CARRIED

 

Present:  John Harrington, Kevin Barry, Bonnie Beaubien, Donald Gorman, Kevin Webber, Tom Haley, Gigi Klipa.

 

            A personnel matter was discussed.

 

At 7:20 P.M. a motion to end the non-public session was made by Kevin Webber, seconded by Bonnie Beaubien.  On a roll call, the board voted:

 

 

 

 

 

John Harrington            YES

                                                       Kevin Barry                   YES

Bonnie Beaubien           YES

Donald Gorman            YES

                                                        Kevin Webber              YES

 

THE MOTION CARRIED

 

        Chair John Harrington noted that no action had been taken in non-public session.

 

Pg. 2 (C, 1st paragraph)

Mrs. Worthen the Special Education Coordinator presented to the DCS board reasons for the increase in the Para line:  33-42.5

Should Read:  Mrs. Worthen the Special Education Coordinator presented to the DCS board reasons for the increase of Para’s from 33 to 42.5

 

Pg. 2 (C, 1st paragraph)

·  A number of students requiring longer programming that was not offered last summer.  They were sent to an outside program.  Next summer she is DCS will have their own program in place.

 

Should Read:  A number of students required longer programming last summer were sent to an outside of district program.  Next summer DCS is planning to have a program in place that is held at DCS not out of district.

 

Pg. 5 (A, 1st paragraph)

Mr. Webber noted that he received an e-mail from Mrs. Clark concerning space needs and Facility Planning.

 

Should Read:  Mr. Harrington noted that he received an e-mail from Mrs. Clark concerning space needs and Facility Planning

 

A motion was made by Kevin Barry to accept the minutes of November 11, 2006 as corrected, seconded, by Don Gorman. 

 

All In Favor

Motion Carried 

 

4.  Immediate Business

 

  1. Agenda Review

No Changes

 

B.     Citizens’ Staff Comments

None were made

 

 

C.     Alternative High School Selections -Mr. Harrington

Mr. Harrington stated that 12 letters concerning alternative high school placement were placed in unmarked envelopes and sealed by Paul Yergeau.  Mr. Harrington informed those present that Mr. Haley the Supt. of SAU 53 would be drawing the names.  As Mr. Haley drew the envelopes they were marked in the order that they were drawn and the names were read:

The names were drawn in the following order:

1.      Gabriel LaRoche

2.      Sam Williams

3.      Justin Bilodeau

4.      Renee Zwick

5.      Abigail Burmeister

6.      Kevin Fahey

7.      Perry Eaton

8.      Taylor Mahoney

9.      Cullen Barnes

10.  Shane Currier

11.  Cam Levasseurer

12.  Ian Johnson

 

Mr. Harrington announced that letters would be sent to the parents informing them of where their names fall on the list.

Mr. Harrington then allowed parents to comment or ask questions. 

Denise Fahey asked if the board approached Concord asking if Deerfield students that wanted to attend an alternative high- school could do so.

Mrs. Fahey also stated that transportation issues are a huge concern to parents and encouraged the board to pursue finding a better way to get Deerfield students to Concord.  Mr. Harrington stated that when Concord is considered the school of record the board would be able to recommend and place in the budget money for high school transportation it then goes to the voters for approval.   Mr. Webber reminded everyone that the town voted down the $75,000 stipend.  Mrs. LeMauk stated that she would be placed in the situation where she will have children at two different schools.  Mr. Gorman reminded those present that the community voted to have a contract with Concord.  This year the Concord contract allows DCS to send 95% of the 8th grade graduating class, next year the formula will be using ADM (average daily membership) based on all attending high school students.  Mrs. LeMauk replied that this situation would create hardships for many families.  Mr. Haley stated that unless Deerfield is willing to pay tuition twice: once for the school of choice and then for the empty seat at Concord there is no other way.  Mr. Gorman stated that the board members have truly looked at the situation from all angles and are very aware of the difficulties but it was becoming necessary to lock into a contract with a high school because placement was becoming increasingly difficult. 

Mr. Harrington stated that Concord was contacted about families that wanted alternative placement and they were not willing to adjust the contract.  Concord will be contacted again to reconsider their decision.

 

At 7:05 Mr. Harrington closed discussion.

 

Mr. Harrington invited Bill Carbeneau a member of  the MBC to the board meeting so that he could  have the questions he had brought forward at a MBC meeting  answered.  Mr. Carbenueau stated that he was not representing the MBC at this time.

 

Question #1:  Mr. Carbonneau asked about the $1,000 stipend for teachers to do certain jobs and how did the school find monies to fund this?

Mr. Harrington replied that the administration adjusted other line items to do so.  The teachers’ that receive this stipend have taken on added responsibilities above and beyond their classroom responsibilities.

Question#2:  When and how did the school decide to have full day kindergarten and if the school knew they were not going to have enough Kindergarten students why did they not decide to cut the teaching position to half-day.

Mr. Barry stated that Kindergarten registration does not take place until contracts have been signed therefore they could not cut the position.

Mr. Yergeau replied that the community overwhelming responded to the full day option

and that there was not added personnel.

Question #3:  Did DCS charge parents for school supplies?

Mr. Yergeau stated that every year parents are asked to assist with basic school supplies such as crayons, markers, etc.

Kevin Webber informed Mr. Carbonneau that the default budget caused the supply line to be reduced as other items or lines were reduced. 

Mr. Carbonneau stated that he wanted to trust the decision making process at DCS and would encourage better communication between the school and the community.

 

*  It was noted that the board was in receipt of a letter from Mrs. LeMauk.

 

D.      Budget Development- Mr. Harrington

 

 A motion was made by Don Gorman, seconded by Kevin Webber that the:

 

  1. Deerfield Community School Board initiates immediately a hiring freeze
  2. This freeze includes all new hires including Special Ed. Positions, Teaching staff, and all other Staff positions
  3. All half-time positions are frozen at present levels
  4. All new hires that replace a vacancy may only take place after review and    approval of the board.
  5. All new contracts or increases over $500 in present contracts regarding Special   Ed. likewise shall be reviewed and approved by the board. Deerfield Community School Board may terminate this freeze by a majority vote of the board at anytime.

 

3 In Favor

2 Against

Motion Carried

 

 

 

 

 

A motion was made to amend the motion (# 2) by Kevin Webber to add without board approval, seconded by Don Gorman.

 

3 In Favor

2 Against

Motion Carried

     

A motion was made to amend the motion (# 5) by Kevin Webber to change $500, to $1,500 seconded by Don Gorman.

 

 

In Favor-4

Abstained-1

Motion Carried

 

Final Draft including amendments.

 

1. Deerfield Community School Board initiates immediately a hiring freeze

2. This freeze includes all new hires including Special Ed. Positions, Teaching staff, and all   other Staff positions.  All new hires may not happen without board approval.

3. All half-time positions are frozen at present levels

4. All new hires that replace a vacancy may only take place after review and    approval of the board.

5. All new contracts or increases over $1,000 in present contracts regarding Special   Ed. likewise shall be reviewed and approved by the board. Deerfield Community School Board may terminate this freeze by a majority vote of the board at anytime.

 

Mr. Gorman stated that he couldn’t see the purpose in expanding programs at DCS with the lack of space.  He stated that the projects are wonderful but paid for by the taxpayers.

Mr. Gorman also stated that the board needs to review Special Ed. spending and maybe say no to adding more para’s.

Ms. Beaubien stated that the board does not have the power to override an IEP.  Ms. Beaubien also stated that Health Care is breaking the backs of American citizens and educating the public would drive down cost and it needs to start at a young age.

Mr. Yergeau stated that sweeping generalizations have been made which are inappropriate.  He further stated that he would not be doing his job if he did not advocate quality programs for the students at DCS   He also stated that DCS has brought back a number of out of district students creating a savings in Special Ed.  Mr. Yergeau also reminded the board members that the numbers of classes have been reduced by 1 teacher.

Mr. Gorman stated that the purpose of his motion was to encourage and bring forward a platform to have an open discussion.

D.     Budget Development-Mr. Harrington

The board reviewed the proposed 07-08 budget.  Please see attached documents for further information.

1. DCS Initiatives 07-08 submitted by Paul Yergeau

2. Deerfield School District Special Education Projection 07-08

3.  07-08 Deerfield Rate Forecast

4.  Dept. of Ed. Release of Equitable Education Aid Figures of 07-08

Mr. Haley noted that the Deerfield District will be receiving a substantial increase in the

FY 08 Equitable Education Aid of $2,117,056.  

Items left in the budget process are Teacher contracts, non-certified staff and 07-08 school initiatives. 

The Sped budget was reviewed again and the summer program will be reduced to 3 days saving ($13,000).  Summer transportation will be reduced.  The total reduction in the budget as if November 6th (which are not reflected in the budget) totals $91,345.

A noted increase in the budget was the substitute teacher.  The SAU compared surrounding communities in the area and $65 is the current rate for most districts.  It is an increase of $5 a day.

ESOL Tutor was discussed by the board.  Mr. Haley informed the board that position

was driven by students who meet a federal standard in language requirements.

The members discussed a textbook request from 7th grade.  Mr. Haley stated that because of state testing and “No Child Left Behind” teachers must now instruct in specific skill areas.  Curriculum is now going back to a very structured format using basil readers.

 

A motion was made by Kevin Webber to remove the grade level stipends from line 001-2213-110-108-000 seconded by Don Gorman.

 

4 In Favor

1 Against

 

The board reviewed each line as needed for clarification.

 

It was noted that the 07-08 proposed budget is a 3.3 increase or 60cents per $1,000

 

A motion was made by Kevin Webber to move the 07-08 budget at $10,789,831.00.

 

All In Favor

Motion Carried

 

07-08 Initiatives

 

Security Increase

The board reviewed the listed equipment required to install a security system at DCS. 

Mr. Webber stated that the board should take the time to look at low-tech before they

They make any changes.

Soundproofing the two Music Rooms

                Discussed at previous meetings.

Changes in Insurance Benefits (To be considers as part of negotiations)

Sub Coordinator Stipend

Several of the board members stated that they were not convinced that a stipend was

the best way to handle extra time spent in finding subs and will discuss this further.

Increase in Secretarial Time

The board discussed the changes in required reporting due to NCLB and the demands it was making on the office personnel. Mrs. Davitt stated that teachers, specialist, and others are asking for more reports to be generated from the student info. system because of state and federal requirements. Appox. 8 years ago the office had green screens and the only info. that was being generated by the office was the School Register, Attendance, School memo, and bridge.  The student information system now holds much more information requiring more data entry work and report making.  Also, the dependence on volunteers has changed due to a decrease in their numbers the office staff has had to pick up a lot of work that once was done by volunteers.

HS Transportation

Due to the difficulty in parents getting their students to Concord, and past board discussions, Mr. Yergeau placed this on the 07-08 Initiatives.

 

Total of 07-08 Initiatives:  $11,358

 

5.   Other Business

 

A.     Informational Items –Administrators and board Members

 

Mr. Harrington asked about the ID badges.  Mr. Yergeau stated that the machine at the Police Dept. has been in repair since the end of August.  Life touch, which is the company that does school pictures, came in for a re-take day and agreed to take the Staff ID’s. 

 

A motion was made by John Harrington that all staff members must have their ID’s as of Dec. 31st.

 

All In Favor

Motion Carried

 

B.     Agenda Preparation-Mr. Harrington

 

Review of budget

 

C.     Citizens’/Staff Comments

 

None Made

 

A.     Non-Public Session-Mr. Gorman

 

At 10:27 P.M., a motion to enter non-public session under RSA 91-A: 3II(c) to discuss a personnel matter was made by Kevin Barry, seconded by Kevin Webber.  On a roll call, the board voted:

 

 

        John Harrington  YES

        Kevin Barry         YES

                                                        Bonnie Beaubien YES

                                                        Donald Gorman   YES

                                                        Kevin Webber      YES

 

                                                  THE MOTION CARRIED

 

            Present:  John Harrington, Kevin Barry, Bonnie Beaubien, Donald Gorman, Kevin Webber, Paul Yergeau, Tom Haley.

 

            The board discussed a personnel matter.

 

            At 10:32 P.M. a motion to end the non-public session was made by Kevin Webber, seconded by Bonnie Beaubien.  On a roll call, the board voted:

 

John Harrington            YES

Kevin Barry                  YES

Bonnie Beaubien           YES

Donald Gorman            YES

Kevin Webber              YES

 

ALL IN FAVOR

THE MOTION CARRIED

 

            Chair John Harrington noted that no action had been taken in non-public session.

 

6. Adjournment

 

At 10:33 P.M. a motion to adjourn was made by Kevin Webber, seconded by Don Gorman.

 

ALL IN FAVOR

THE MOTION CARRIED

 

There is a meeting of the M.B.C. scheduled for December 5, 2006 to review the school district budget.

 

The next Deerfield School Board meeting is scheduled for Thursday, December 7, 2006 at 6:30 P.M.